Have you ever wondered if electronic drums are really worth it? Whether you’re looking for a practice solution or a full-time kit alternative, there are some key things to consider before making the jump. In this post, I’ll break down whether I’d recommend electronic drums, when they make sense, and when they might actually hold you back.
Hi! And welcome back to the channel. Don’t forget to like and subscribe if you haven’t already. Let’s begin…
Electronic drum kits have come a long way over the years. They offer a quiet, space-saving way to practice, and some of the high-end models even feel close to an acoustic kit. But remember what I said in the previous post. So, can they truly replace an acoustic drum set? The short answer: It depends on your situation.
If you’re in a situation where practicing on an acoustic kit isn’t an option—maybe because of noise restrictions—then an electronic kit can be a great alternative. They allow you to practice essential techniques, timing, and coordination without disturbing the neighbors. And you can do this on a three hundred dollar kit if you like.
However, if your goal is to develop true control, feel, and dynamics, electronic kits can have limitations. I always recommend using them as a practice tool rather than a replacement for acoustic drums. One of the biggest challenges is that electronic drums don’t always respond the same way as acoustic drums. Ghost notes, accents, and subtle dynamic shifts can get lost due to the way triggering works.
Electronic kits can sound great but in my personal experience, and being one who prefers acoustic drums. Electronic kits only really work well when you know what you are doing within your Digital Audio Workstation too. Processing, compression, E Q, effects and so on.
Now, let’s break it down further. But remember, this is my own personal view only. Others may be different and that’s fine:
The Pros of Electronic Drums:
- Quiet Practice – E-Kits are Perfect for apartments or shared spaces where noise is an issue.
- Compact & Portable – They take up less space and so they can be set up in smaller areas.
- Built-in Sounds & Features – Many kits come with built-in metronomes, play-along tracks, and recording or looping options.
- Easy Recording – Ideal for home studios or direct-to-DAW recording without the need for microphones.
- Easy Recording – Ideal for home studios or direct-to-digital workstation recording without the need for microphones.
The Cons of Electronic Drums:
- Lack of True Feel – Mesh heads and rubber pads don’t fully replicate the response of acoustic drums. In my opinions, the rubber pads are closer to hitting a real drum than the mesh heads.Hitting a real drum is closer to a hard surface, not like the bouncy mesh heads. They may bounce like a real drum, a little. But the initial stroke isn’t as harsh.
- Limited Dynamics – Electronic kits often compress sound, making soft ghost notes and dynamic control harder to develop. I still believe this even though most companies boast real-feel experiences.
- Triggering Issues – Some, rather, most kits struggle with accurately triggering fast playing or subtle nuances.
- Expensive for a Good Kit – Entry-level models may not provide the feel and features needed for serious playing. And a leap into a more expensive kit in the beginning is really a necessity. Unless you are treating it purely as a practice kit.
If you absolutely have to go electronic, make sure to choose a model that allows for sensitivity adjustments and realistic pad feel. If that’s even possible. And be prepared to learn some mixing and processing techniques with the audio workstation.
But if you have the option, I’d always recommend supplementing an electronic kit with an acoustic kit when possible.
So, are electronic drums right for you? Only if you need them for a specific purpose. They work best as an addition to an acoustic kit, not a complete replacement. But remember, this is my opinion and perspective only. What are your thoughts on the subject? Let us know in the comments.
Thanks for listening, watching, or reading this series. For now this is the end of this series. But who knows, I may be asked other important questions and decide to add them.
I will be adding them to the common Drumming Questions Book you can get for free by visiting drummingfoundation.com.
And if you haven’t already, be sure to checkout the Drumming Chronicles playlist for more common questions answered.
Until next time. Keep learning and developing and the very best of luck to you.
